Material Elements of the Crime of Assault on the State’s Airspace: A Comparative Study

Abstract

This article provides a comprehensive legal analysis of the crime of assault on the state’s airspace by examining the material element as articulated in criminal law theory and national legislation. Building on classical definitions of actus reus, the study explores how external physical conduct—such as unauthorized entry, deviation from air routes, low-altitude violations, misuse of transit and innocent passage, aircraft hijacking, and drone or missile incursions—constitutes the observable basis for criminal liability in the aerial domain. The research emphasizes that airspace violations generate both material results, including physical damage and safety hazards, and legal results, such as infringements on sovereignty, disruption of national security, and intelligence exposure. The analysis also details the evidentiary challenges in establishing causation, particularly in cases involving unmanned aerial vehicles, cyber interference, and ballistic missiles, where radar tracking, satellite imagery, and aviation logs play critical roles. A comparative study of Iraqi, Egyptian, and Emirati legislation reveals distinct approaches to defining and criminalizing airspace violations. Iraq provides a clear conceptual definition of the material element but lacks technological updates addressing drones and missiles. Egypt relies on sector-based aviation regulation without a unified doctrinal structure, creating fragmentation and interpretive challenges. The United Arab Emirates offers the most advanced framework, integrating international conventions, detailed domestic provisions, and modern technological controls governing UAVs and cyber threats. The findings demonstrate that modern airspace regulation requires cohesive legislative reform, strong alignment with international standards, and explicit recognition of emerging forms of aerial misconduct. The study concludes by proposing legislative pathways for strengthening national airspace protection in an era of rapidly evolving aerial technologies.